A plea for renewable solutions

THE EDITOR, Madam:

I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the recent discourse on nuclear energy, specifically small modular reactors (SMRs), as a viable energy solution for Jamaica. While pathetically unqualified proponents, rich salesmen, and innocent billionaires argue for their potential, I believe a shift towards renewable energy sources presents a far more practical, safe, and sustainable path for our nation.

The arguments for SMRs in Jamaica appear deeply flawed. First, the technology remains largely in the design phase, with uncertain timelines for deployment. This inherent uncertainty casts serious doubts on the viability of SMRs as a timely solution for our pressing energy needs.

Further, I fear that the allure of nuclear energy stems from misplaced priorities. The pursuit of SMRs seems driven by a misguided quest for personal wealth by ‘the few’ and a dangerous disregard for the welfare of our many vulnerable people. The potential risks associated with nuclear technology, including the complexities of waste management and the potential for catastrophic accidents, far outweigh any perceived benefits. No amount of ‘depopulation’ of southern St Catherine and Clarendon is prudent, palatable, or politically permissible if what was recently mused in the presence of the press.

In stark contrast, renewable energy technologies, such as solar, wind, and farmed biomass, are readily available and increasingly affordable. Besides, such sources guarantee long-term, safe, and well-paying jobs. Advances in battery storage technology further enhance the viability of these renewable sources, making them a practical and obvious choice for Jamaica’s energy future.

Investing in renewable energy offers numerous advantages. It reduces our carbon footprint, minimises environmental risks, and enhances our energy independence by diversifying our energy sources.

I urge Jamaican policymakers to carefully consider the long-term implications of their energy decisions. The pursuit of nuclear energy even by SMRs is a risky and potentially disastrous path. Let us instead embrace the promise of renewable energy, ensuring a sustainable and prosperous future for generations to come.

Are Jamaicans wiser than the Australians, Costa Ricans, Dominicanos, Cubanos, Finns, Germans, Swedes, Danes, South Koreans, Ghanaians, Barbadians, or Spaniards, to name just a dozen countries with pellucidly clear renewable energy transition policy commitments? By the way, there is absolutely nothing ‘renewable’ about any nuclear technology.

DENNIS MINOTT, PhD